Caroline is Writing

a blog by a writer attempting to live the literary good life on the internet
3 min read Permalink

Jandy Mac Comes Back by Elsie J. Oxenham

A somewhat bewildering plunge into the later stretch of the Abbey Series.
This is my copy of Jandy Mac Comes Back, the 1952 Collins edition.

Jandy Mac Comes Back is a grand reunion in book form. I imagine that a devoted Elsie J. Oxenham reader devouring it when it was first published in 1941 would have revelled in all of the detail about what beloved characters from earlier titles in the Abbey series have been doing since they left school and got married. But for me, a relative newcomer, it was a bit confusing.

Among Elsie J. Oxenham aficionados, Jandy Mac Comes Back is known as "A29" and the start of a run of books known as the "Second Generation Titles". I've only read two other Abbey books so far, both of which I picked up at random earlier in 2025 (Maid of the Abbey in July and The Abbey Girls in Town in August) but I'm slowly getting to grips with the overlapping chronology and recurring, multi-generational character structure. Still, a lot of the references in this one went over my head and I had to do some extra research to make sense of all the characters that have names beginning with J. Allison Thompson's Abbey writings have been particularly helpful for this.

This is a reunion story in every sense. "Jandy Mac" of the title, Janice Fraser née MacDonald, has returned to England after many years married life in Samoa and Australia. With her is her thirteen year old daughter Joan, named after one of Jandy's schoolfriends and main Abbey girl, Joan Shirley. Jandy has decided to surprise her friends by turning up at their homes after over a decade away with no warning. Fairly predictably, this goes wrong. The friends are either away from home or, in Joan's case, have just that morning given birth to a new baby. Luckily, Jandy and her Joan (aka "Littlejan" or "Joan-Two" to avoid confusion) are scooped up by another Abbey girl, Rosamund, now Lady Kentisbury, and taken to stay in her castle while other friends are tracked down.

Everyone gradually gets up to date on each other's family histories, and there are a few surprises and adventures too. One Abbey girl, Jen, makes a sudden departure to Yorkshire (and out of the book's narrative) when her husband is in a car accident at their farm there. Then the world of Kentisbury Castle (apparently based on Arundel) is rocked when kidnappers, working in collusion with the Earl's chauffeur, steal several of the household's children in the hope of ransoming the heir. Jandy, her daughter, and the housekeeper's niece Tansy all perform various acts of heroism. Soon, all children have been returned to their rightful place unharmed and the malefactors are in custody. The gratitude expressed towards Jandy Mac and her daughter renew their ties to the Abbey crowd and promise greater interaction in future books. Unlike in the other two I've read, there is no folk dancing or May queen stuff in this one, which was slightly disappointing.

My other quibble with this book concerns Jandy Mac's great act of heroism. She happens to be riding towards the picnic cove as the children are being abducted and sees the struggle. Tansy and three kids are taken away on a boat, while Jandy's daughter Joan is left lying on the shore, perhaps unconscious, perhaps dead. Instead of going to her aid, Jandy turns her horse around and gallops straight back to the castle's village to raise the alarm. Afterwards, she is much praised for overcoming the maternal instinct to care for her child in order to protect the kidnapped heir to the castle.

This reads strangely to the modern eye. Without any way of getting help other than going herself, Jandy did have to think and act quickly, and the kidnappers were already away. But it's odd that she doesn't even do a quick triage check of the survivor before riding off — and even odder that this, more than her fast and daring riding, is what she's lauded for. Given how focused the rest of the book is on the demands of motherhood above all else, this felt out of place and reminded me of the similarly illogical behaviour during the kidnapping plot in Elinor M. Brent-Dyer's The Princess of the Chalet School. I know expecting realism from early twentieth century school stories is silly, but characters usually behave with some internal consistency to their world!

Despite this, and despite the fact that for me reading this book is a bit like overhearing a reunion conversation between people you don't know, I still enjoyed it, which I think is testament to Oxenham's breezy prose and knack for stringing events together with good momentum. As my experience shows, you can read it without a full knowledge of everything that has gone before, but it might be better if you do come upon it in the proper seqeuence. I feel like I'm inching ever closer to having to become a non-casual Abbey fan and actually start reading these books in order...

Filed under: Blog, Book Review
9 min read Permalink

Wickham, Wimsey, Westmacott: What I Read in October, November and December 2025

October:

Hallowe'en Party by Agatha Christie

I re-read this for the Halloween episode of Shedunnit, and was pleased to find it better than I remembered. There's a folk horror, pagan element to it that I rather enjoyed.


Third Girl by Agatha Christie

A less successful Christie, mostly because of her attempts to be up to date. She tried to fold details about youth culture and drug taking into the story when she clearly didn't know very much about them. I did, however, enjoy Mrs Oliver's antics in this book, especially the bit where she tails a suspect across London and then ends up having tea with them.


An Unsuitable Heir by K.J. Charles

I read this on the recommendation of a blog reader (thank you, Theodora!) and ended up agreeing with her that K.J. Charles writes good romance-mystery hybrids that are straightforward enough to read for relaxation but sufficiently well-written that your brain doesn't snag on any rough edges. This one was a queer nineteenth century romance that included some discussion of gender fluidity, circus/music hall performing, and ghosts. I'll pick up other books by this author when I'm in the right mood, for sure.


Giant's Bread by Mary Westmacott

A work project that I can't talk about yet required me to re-read all six of the Mary Westmacott books (written by Agatha Christie under a penname) in a short space of time. I've covered them on Shedunnit before but haven't looked at them in at least five years and arrived at some new insights this time around, probably because I've advanced in my knowledge of the Christie canon quite a lot in that time. I do think all six are worth reading. In this one, I was rather struck by the details about music, which was Christie's first choice for a career (she was a talented singer and pianist).


A Rising Man by Abir Mukherjee

This was the Shedunnit Book Club's November book and my detailed thoughts on it are available to members over there. In brief: I found the setting in Raj-era India fascinating, the mystery just ok, and the author's choice of first-person narration frustrating.


Unfinished Portrait by Mary Westmacott

The correspondences between this second Westmacott novel and the sections of Agatha Christie's autobiography (which she didn't start writing for a couple of decades after this) are very striking. All of her youthful courtship details are the same and the failed marriage of "Celia" and "Dermot" is very similar to that of Agatha and Archie Christie. It actually made me wonder about the extent to which Christie's memories were shaped by working on this novel in the early 1930s, and whether that was what she was remembering, rather than the actual events, when she came to write her memoirs.


The Impossible Fortune by Richard Osman

A new Thursday Murder Club novel, consumed as an audiobook. It was just OK for me, this time. I still regret the loss of Lesley Manville as the original reader of the series (sorry, Fiona Shaw). I also feel like any attempt at serious mystery plotting has been shelved in favour of dialogue and character stuff, which doesn't work as well for me.


Pride and Prescience by Carrie Bebris

Another instalment in my continued and never-ending effort to read every Austen spin-off ever written. This series is a crime fiction crossover, with a now-married Darcy and Elizabeth taking on the role of "detectives" when things go awry in their social circle. In this one, Caroline Bingley has married a rich American and started behaving very strangely. Then, while everyone is staying at Netherfield Park, a murder takes place... A decent premise, but stilted dialogue and a slow-moving plot meant it disappointed, and I won't be continuing the series.


November:

Penhallow by Georgette Heyer

Now, this is a book I've thought about a lot since I finished it. I read and largely enjoyed all of Heyer's twelve detective novels this year as I was making a podcast episode about them, and this was the standout. Perhaps because it's barely a detective novel at all, but rather a grim, Gothic portrait of a family being controlled by a brutal patriarch on a remote estate in Cornwall. Shades of Rebecca, for sure. According to her biographer Jennifer Kloester, Heyer personally considered this to be one of her best books and was rather disappointed when the reading public didn't agree. I think I might, though! There is a murder plot in it, of a sort, but now that I've read some of Heyer's historical fiction this feels like a bridge between her work in the two different genres.


Duplicate Death by Georgette Heyer

Here, Heyer was on much safer ground, genre-wise — this is a traditional whodunnit, set around a card party at a fancy London house and detected by her recurring detective, Inspector Hemingway. After I mentioned this book in passing on the podcast, a bridge expert felt compelled to get in touch to point out that the "duplicate bridge" aspect of the plot doesn't really work, but since I don't know what that is anyway it didn't bother me. Perfectly readable, and with the usual Heyer sharpness of wit and description.


The Rasp by Philip Macdonald

I had heard bad things about this book from a fellow devotee of interwar crime fiction. But despite the dire warnings, I had a generally good time reading it. It felt to me like a mid-1920s hybrid, with MacDonald including both R. Austin Freeman-style forensic investigation of footprints and more thriller-ish elements such as you find in an early Christie like The Secret Adversary. Sometimes these two styles vie for the reader's attention in an irritating fashion, but mostly I wasn't bothered by it. I liked the early details about contemporary journalism and liked the amateur sleuth MacDonald sets up here, Anthony Gethryn. What this book has over and above everything else is vim and purpose: the narrative momentum is so great that it positively zips along. When I discussed this book with my guest for the podcast episode, I learned a lot about MacDonald's subsequent screenwriting work, and this unlocked a whole new appreciate in me for what he does with structure in this book. Have a listen to the Shedunnit episode about it.


Absent in the Spring by Mary Westmacott

I am convinced that this was Agatha Christie's experiment with horror fiction. It follows a self-satisfied, middle class English woman as she travels back home from visiting her married daughter in Baghdad. Owing to some bad weather, she misses a connection and has to wait for an unknown number of days at a remote rest-house on the Turkish border until the next train can get through. She quickly finishes the small amount of reading material she has with her and runs out of writing paper. There is nothing to do and nobody to talk to, beyond the staff who have no interest in engaging with her.

For the first time in her life, she has nothing but her own mind to fill her days. She takes desultory walks in the surrounding desert, reliving happy memories of her wonderful husband, lovely children, and attentive neighbours. But the more she thinks about her life, the more she comes to realise that she has been living in a smug, self-centred bubble, absolutely unaware of what is really going on around her. Her husband was relieved that she was going away on a long trip because he finds her hard work to live with. Her children pity her and have made hasty, unsuitable marriages to get away from her. The neighbours she has looked down on with their coarse, inferior lives were actually much better off — happy, together, honest. It's an intense and fascinating psychological portrait. Christie wrote this book in three days straight without sleeping, during WW2, and the intensity of tone and the narrative momentum is consistent with this kind of creation. I'd highly recommend it.


The Rose and the Yew Tree by Mary Westmacott

The back half of the Westmacott half dozen is a bit less rewarding. The overarching storyline of this one makes me go "hmmm". I do, however, like the details of a post-WW2 parliamentary election campaign, supposedly gathered by Christie from the experiences of her nephew Jack Watts.


A Daughter's A Daughter by Mary Westmacott

Originally a play and I can imagine it being better in that format. Still, a very clear-sighted and not especially flattering viewpoint on motherhood, written by someone who was mother to an adult daughter who hated this piece of work.


The Burden by Mary Westmacott

The final Westmacott and, like the one above, centred around quasi-parental relationships and the tensions thereof. My main observation coming out of this one: for someone who didn't write much in her crime fiction about children, Christie really loved to write about childhood.


The Nine Tailors by Dorothy L. Sayers

This was the Shedunnit Book Club's December book and my detailed thoughts on it are available to members over there. I already knew that I liked this book a lot (bellringing, crime fiction and East Anglia being three of my favourite things) but on this re-read I unlocked a whole new level of love for it.


The Murder of Mr Wickham by Claudia Gray

Another Austen follow-on, again with a crime slant. Wickham, for obvious reasons, is a popular murder victim in this type of book (P.D. James is not alone in thinking that, although for me, Death Comes to Pemberley was far too weighed down with all the period research she had done to be a good read). I liked this one best of all the Austen-crimes I have read so far, principally because Gray does a great job of blending all the characters from all the different Austen novels together into one wide circle of acquaintance so she has plenty of scope (she explains her reasoning regarding timelines in an explanatory preface). Thus, our amateur detectives are Mr Jonathan Darcy (son of Darcy and Elizabeth) and Miss Juliet Tilney (daughter of Catherine from Northanger Abbey), and they detect a crime that takes place in the home of Emma and Mr Knightley. I will read more of these!


The Victorian Prizefighters series by Alice Coldbreath (three books)

In a similar vein to the K.J. Charles book mentioned above, these are well-structured but quite repetitive historical romance novels that I read either when travelling in hard-to-concentrate circumstances (in this case, incredibly busy and loud trains to a conference) or when extremely tired. If you have similar need for a brain-break but find a lot of supposedly "cosy" fiction frustratingly badly written, these might work for you (as long as you can handle the occasional spicy scene).


December:

Detection Unlimited by Georgette Heyer

The twelfth Heyer detective novel is something of an anticlimax, being very far from her best either in plot or character terms. I'm glad I managed to read all of them this year, though.


Elephants Can Remember by Agatha Christie

Another re-read for an upcoming podcast episode. This one still isn't a favourite of mine, even though I am fond of Mrs Oliver. By 1972, at the age of 82, I think Christie was a bit tired of writing mystery novels.


The Documents in the Case by Dorothy L. Sayers and Robert Eustace

This is the next title in my Green Penguin Book Club series on the podcast and a book I have a real soft spot for. Probably because it's Dorothy L. Sayers at her most peculiar: there's no Peter Wimsey, no conventional mystery structure, and no well-developed characters who go on a journey through the novel. Just 53 documents, laying out the inner lives of the inhabitants of a suburban London villa in the early 1930s and the horrible crime that gets committed as a result. The episode will be out in January.


The Murder of Roger Ackroyd by Agatha Christie

This is the Shedunnit Book Club's chosen book for January! Join us if you'd like to discuss it together.


The Adventures of Dagobert Trostler by Balduin Groller

These are short stories starring the "Sherlock Holmes of Vienna", the titular amateur detective, Dagobert Trostler. I really enjoyed these and would have read lots more, but I have so far struggled to find any more English translations beyond the Kazabo edition. If you have any leads for me, please get in touch.


A Case of Life and Limb by Sally Smith

A Christmas present, devoured in one day on 26th December! I recorded this time last year how much I enjoyed the first book in this historical mystery series set in the Inner Temple in the early 1900s, and the second book held up well. Here's hoping Smith keeps up her schedule so I can keep getting these as gifts for some years to come.


These Old Shades by Georgette Heyer

More on this to come in my next reading email...


Carrington's Cases by J. Storer Clouston

Another Christmas gift — a lovely collection of mystery short stories by an Orkney-born writer from the golden age of detective fiction. I suspect my husband worked quite hard to track this down, but if you do get a chance to pick up a copy, it's well worth it.


That was, belatedly, my reading for October, November and December: 28 books across three months, bringing to 121 for the year (if I finish any others in the remaining three days of December, I'll update the total in the next update). I just hit my target of 120 books read in 2025.

I'll have more coherent thoughts about my year of reading and what I plan to do in 2026 for you next week. Thanks for scrolling this far through all of that — I hope you found something to try reading yourself. If you would like to follow along in real time, you can see what I'm reading at any given moment on the Storygraph.

Filed under: Reading Updates, Blog
1 min read Permalink

Someone Who Has Become Very Curmudgeonly In Recent Years

Thirteen things this Thursday that I have read, watched, listened to or otherwise found noteworthy.

The most popular link last time was the pixelated fireplace, with this piece about the age (44) at which millennial women begin to feel old second.

  1. Did Jane Austen Invent the Wellness Guy? Yes she did! And there's a whole section in my most recent book (which could still be purchased as a holiday gift, there is time) about this!
  2. Almost nobody writes little memoir vignettes as well as Jean Hannah Edelstein, in my opinion. This one — "A silver clutch that I last used at a wedding" — is wonderful.
  3. When Secret Santa goes wrong: I still think sometimes about the time, 15+ years ago, when a colleague bought me a bag of penis-shaped pasta seemingly as a way to initiate a conversation about my sexuality at the work Christmas party. If only it was a workplace with an HR department...
  4. Spend a week on the Swiss rail system via this video.
  5. Some good tips on writing from a former magazine editor. My favourite is: "Learn to think like a fact-checker".
  6. This BBC list of "ten of the greatest murder mysteries ever" was surprisingly good, and I say that as someone who has become very curmudgeonly in recent years about the apparent nosedive in people's ability to tell what is good in crime fiction.
  7. On Being Interested in Stuff Almost No One is Interested In.
  8. It's harder than it might seem for farmers to stop using plastic.
  9. When Maga came for Calibri, what did you do?
  10. Am I Divorced? A single man wonders.
  11. The finalists for the 2025 Comedy Wildlife Awards.
  12. Soman Chainani writes global YA bestselling novels. He also writes really beautiful blog posts about his partner's farm in Missouri, such as this one about how their herd took care of an accidental early calf during a snowstorm.
  13. This one is for the people who remember when I used to do the "compulsory medieval thingamabob" at the end of every newsletter.

Filed under: Blog, Links
4 min read Permalink

Summer, Station, Scene: What I Read in September 2025

Dead Man's Folly by Agatha Christie

I was a reader of Christie long before I saw any of the film or TV adaptations, so I formed my own imaginary versions of her characters long before I saw any actors interpreting them. But for some reason, with this book only, the 2013 ITV version with David Suchet and Zoe Wanamaker as Hercule Poirot and Ariadne Oliver dominates my mental image of it. Perhaps it's because it was filmed at Greenway, the very house that Christie had in mind when she was writing it? I'm not sure. Anyway, I found myself favourably impressed by the plot upon this re-read, given that this is not a book that is usually named as a top tier Christie mystery. She did a good job here of marrying the old and the new, combining a classic country house setting with some hints of social change. I'm writing about this book shortly for an episode of Shedunnit, so look out for that if you want more extended thoughts on it.


What Abigail Did That Summer and The Furthest Station by Ben Aaronovitch

My audiobook re-listen of the Rivers of London series continues with two of the novellas. I really like both of these stories because they give me my favourite things about Aaronovitch's work — the magic and the London history — without the bit I like least, which is the police procedure and the multi-book nemesis. What Abigail Did That Summer cleverly fills the reader in on what was happening in the capital while usual protagonist Peter Grant was off on a rural case in Foxglove Summer, with his cousin Abigail as narrator. She gets in with a gang of talking foxes on Hampstead Heath, makes a new friend, and gets trapped in a century-old timeloop in a very posh house. Shvorne Marks narrates what I think might be my favourite book in the series so far.

The Furthest Station, another novella, is also great for readers with my preferences, as it's a magical ghost story set in Metroland (ie, along the northern extent of the Metropolitan line). John Betjeman fans, swoon with me. Unlike Abigail, this one stars Peter Grant again and does a great job of running a historical mystery in parallel with a contemporary one, another favourite trope of mine. At about four hours, an excellent listen when you want something engrossing and escapist but can't face committing to another 10+ hour audiobook.


Green for Danger by Christianna Brand

This was the October book for my podcast's book club and a novel I was delighted to revisit — truly one of the best WW2 mysteries and such a clever plot. I've talked at length about it already so I won't repeat myself, but I highly recommend this and the 1946 film starring Alastair Sim.


Going Postal by Terry Pratchett

I mentioned this back in April: I really enjoy the type of book where someone reluctant ends up being terrifically competent and guiding an institution towards a good outcome. And this Discworld book about a convicted thief having to rescue a city's neglected post office and bring it back into operation absolutely scratches this itch for me. The sub-plot involving a cabal of investors who ruin the "clacks" — a semaphore-based telegraph system, basically the technological advance that has killed off the post — felt quite prophetic on this reread given the state of the tech companies these days... I'm only a casual Pratchett-enjoyer (I think I've read about half a dozen of his books, total?) but I've listened to the unabridged audiobook of this one at least three times.


A Rare Book of Cunning Device by Ben Aaronovitch

I fear I am becoming a Ben Aaronovitch completist. This was a short short story that he wrote for an event, now recorded by superb Rivers of London narrator Kobna Holdbrook-Smith. It's brief — under thirty minutes — and the plot is correspondingly simple. Since I love bibliomysteries, I kind of wish he had developed this idea of a sentient book roaming the British Library stacks into something longer.


Let's Make a Scene by Laura Wood

This is a gorgeous novel, a second-chance romance about two actors who originally meet (and clash, despite obvious chemistry) in their youth when they are both cast in a period drama film. It's all made much worse by the fact that the studio puts them in a fake PR relationship to promote the film. At the end of the press tour, they part ways and mutually agree never to speak again. Then they have to come together again thirteen years later to make the sequel. The original film has become a cult classic and their careers have gone in very different directions: formerly inexperienced Cynthie is now an Oscars darling, and alleged nepo baby Jack is doing a vampire TV show, to the disgust of his snobby thespian parents. When the pair reunite, they don't seem to hate each other anymore...

I follow Laura Wood's work because she is an Eva Ibbotson fan and I feel that influence strongly in her fiction. For me, this is her best novel yet — funny, clever, sharp and moving. The passages that deal with Cynthie's "cancellation" because of her affair with a married director are nuanced and feel accurate but don't overwhelm with their topicality, while Jack's struggles with his family and their legacy are likewise handled with a light touch. Wood thanks Emma Thompson in the acknowledgements for writing the The Sense and Sensibility Diaries, which gave her insight into what it's like to make a really good small-budget Austen adaptation, and you can feel that influence. Probably the highest praise I can give this book is that it reads like the off-camera romance you wanted from Sense and Sensibility or the 1995 Pride and Prejudice series.


The Pale Horse by Agatha Christie

Another reread in advance of writing that podcast episode I mentioned up top. My opinions are divided on this 1961 Christie. The solution is fantastic and the creepy misdirection layered on top is pretty good, but I really dislike a lot of the "young people are so dirty and modern" stuff. It's there at least in part because Christie is trying to give her middle-aged male narrator a distinct point of view, but there's enough of it that it was grating on me by the end of the book. I would have preferred more about the witches, honestly, but that's just me.


That was, belatedly, my reading for September: 7 books, bringing me up to 93 for the year to date. I'm a couple of books ahead of the pace needed to hit my target of 120 books read in 2025.

If you would like to follow along in real time, you can see what I'm reading at any given moment on the Storygraph. I just use that as a tracker, though, I don't publish any reviews there. I am trying to catch up with these reviews before the end of the year...

Filed under: Blog, Reading Updates
2 min read Permalink

When The Writing Is Very Good That Doesn't Matter

Thirteen things this Thursday that I have read, watched, listened to or otherwise found noteworthy.

The most popular link last time was this list of things that aren't doing the thing, with this piece wondering if you are Actually Trying second.


  1. Somehow, the most insightful thing I have read/seen about contemporary social media usage is this Google Slides presentation. It's got over 400 slides but they're really quick to tap through; it's almost like a flipbook. The primary takeaway is: be weird and don't care about what everyone else is doing.
  2. May you never be too old or jaded to have a good cry at an xkcd comic.
  3. I was surprised to find myself both gripped and moved by this essay by Brandon Taylor about starting playing tennis because he was lonely and then going to a fancy tennis camp in the south of France instead of celebrating Thanksgiving. I don't care about this sport or celebrate that holiday, but when the writing is very good that doesn't matter. I really recognised this bit: "At one point, I had what I thought were friends, and at another, seemingly overnight, no one spoke to me or tried to see me, and what I had were in fact reciprocal story likes on Instagram."
  4. It is essential that you watch this video all the way through.
  5. On virtuosity vs "performing" virtuosity.
  6. A report on a visit to the "Bop House", a three-storey penthouse in Florida where six attractive young women are turbo-charging their OnlyFans operation.
  7. If you have even the slightest interest in how the internet works, this is a good click.
  8. An enumeration of all the different types of scams out there targeting writers. I would add, these also exist for podcasts — the number of emails I get offering me "free promotion on Apple Podcasts for the low starting price of $50" is quite astonishing.
  9. An antidote to the greatest scam of them all: Spotify's harvesting of your personal data and then somehow convincing you to do free marketing for them at the most lucrative time of year! This phenomenon also goes by the name of "Spotify Unwrapped". I've got back into using LastFM this year and I highly recommend it if you like data about your music consumption.
  10. The Last Video Rental Store Is Your Public Library. I co-sign this! DVD/CD players are very cheap these days, and you can borrow all the audiobooks and films you like without paying a monthly fee.
  11. A random Wikipedia page I enjoyed: Ice cream barge.
  12. The first of a four-part essay on "the devoid", a twenty-first century Gothic space.
  13. MacKenzie Scott, ex-wife of Jeff Bezos, is quietly disrupting the world of high-level philanthropy by... just giving worthy organisations money without attaching any conditions. A revolutionary thought!

Filed under: Blog, Links
1 min read Permalink

Win The Right To Supply The President With Baguettes

Thirteen things this Thursday that I have read, watched, listened to or otherwise found noteworthy.

The most popular link last time was this piece about packing for a 25-city book tour, with this look at Dua Lipa's dream job second.


  1. If you're a productive procrastinator like me, you might need this: Things That Aren't Doing the Thing.
  2. Pictures of Glenn Gould at the piano in 1956.
  3. I love a very specific Wikipedia page, such as this one for the "Concours de la meilleure baguette de Paris". If you win this contest, you get a medal, 4,000 euros, and the right to supply the French president with baguettes for the year. And presumably bragging rights over all the other Parisian bakers.
  4. I enjoyed this book extract exploring the possibility that the first aliens to reach Earth might not be the super science-y ones.
  5. The novelists are fighting (over desks).
  6. Smart analysis of the new social media paradigm, where "your content either gets seen by no one or everyone". If you're a company or a person trying to do something tangible with your posts, that's tough. The "middle lane", where at least your followers would see what you were posting, is now gone.
  7. Lovely ideas for how to fill a sketchbook.
  8. Why don't people return their trolleys (or shopping carts, if you're of that persuasion) after using them? Lots of reasons, most of them bad! It's a fascinating microcosm for studying civic behaviour.
  9. I felt extremely targeted (in a good way, ultimately) by this piece about "selective agency in capable people": Maybe you’re not Actually Trying.
  10. Why Is Everyone’s Robot Folding Clothes? Because we've only just started to be able to make robots that can fold clothes, it looks impressive, and it conceals the things that robots still aren't good at.
  11. The future of publishing isn't AI, it's small presses.
  12. We have emoji because of a physics joke gone wrong.
  13. I have been known to snark a bit about romantasy. It's not for me! But I also like to read decent criticism about it, and this is a great example of that.

Filed under: Blog, Links
8 min read Permalink

Santa, Sorcery, Skara: What I Read in August 2025

Envious Casca by Georgette Heyer

This 1941 detective novel has been republished recently under the title A Christmas Party, part of what I think is an attempt to capitalise on the popularity of classic crime novels for the festive season. As Heyer expert Jennifer Kloester explains here, this was a phrase that Heyer herself used to refer to the book during the writing process, so it's not an unjustified rebranding. (Heyer also considered several other titles, including Death Before Dinner and Without Enchantment.) However, I agree with her final choice: Envious Casca comes from Act III Scene II of Shakespeare's Julius Caesar, with the full quotation being "Look, in this place ran Cassius’ dagger through. / See what a rent the envious Casca made." It encapsulates all of the principal elements of the book — surprise betrayal, death by stabbing, and theatricality. Although I can see why some readers might find this an unnecessarily obscure choice, as an ardent Sayers fan, when reading crime fiction I personally enjoy the process of tracking down a literary reference and pondering what the writer meant by its use.

My one quarrel with the switch to A Christmas Party and the snowy cover is that it sets expectations this book cannot meet. This is not a light-hearted or festive book in the least — nothing like other examples of late 1930s/early 1940s festive crime fiction such as Murder After Christmas or The Santa Klaus Murder. The family that Heyer gathers all hate each other, a dynamic made much worse by the insistence of one character that they play nice and be jolly for a Christmas celebration nobody wants. The relentless unpleasantness grows wearying for the reader and I was surprised to find that Heyer had chosen not to include much, if any, of her trademark witty dialogue or give us any clearly redeemable characters for respite. The arrival of the murder is a relief, because it channels the book's energy away from the sheer horribleness of its characters. It is well done, but it's not at all what you might expect if you pick up the cosy-looking reprint. One advantage of being so behind with these reading updates is that at the time of writing I've now read all of Heyer's detective fiction and I can now see that this book is, in a sense, a sketch for her 1943 novel Penhallow, which does far more interesting things with a highly toxic, isolated family. Look out for my thoughts on that book in November's reading post!


The Midnight Bargain by C.L. Polk

I've been exploring Regency-set fantasy fiction lately, and this 2020 novel came up during my research. It's set in a world with something approximating a season and a marriage market to facilitate matches between elite families, but there is also a strong magical presence. Great skill with sorcery can translate into fortune, rank and success. But only men are permitted to study and practice magic, because it is believed that if women do so, they endanger their childbearing abilities.

The main character, Beatrice, is a magically-talented young woman trying to rebel against these gender norms. While publicly pursuing the advantageous society marriage her indebted family desperately needs, in secret she chases after the books and allies that will allow her to master her powers. It's all very promising and I largely enjoyed this book. I had two major quibbles with it, though. Firstly, the relationship between Beatrice and her love interest develops far too quickly — I wanted much more caution and tension to make the payoff feel more earned. And secondly, I found the physical world of this book blurry and indistinct. I appreciate that the writer was prioritising action and plot, but since this was obviously set in an invented place, I could have done with more physical description of it.


The Abbey Girls in Town by Elsie J. Oxenham

After my initial foray into the Abbey series last month, I just happened to come across another of the titles in a secondhand bookshop and so continued my exploration. I read both out of order, so a little bit of detective work was required to work out where I was in the chronology, but it wasn't too bad. In this tale, we meet two new girls, sisters, living together in a London flat, who have got to know the Abbey girls through country dancing (which they are all obsessed with, Cecil Sharp and the folk music revival being in full swing of course). The elder of the pair is keen to write but is suffering from what I suspect we would now call clinical depression. Her struggles to climb out of her mental darkness coupled with how she grapples with the insensitivities of those around her are portrayed in a nuanced and interesting way. And then there's also just lots of passages about women learning country dancing in the 1920s. If you're not a keen school story reader, this combination probably sounds bizarre, but I promise it works! I'm still not ready to commit to becoming a full-on Abbey collector, but I'll continue to pick them up when I come across them.


The Duke and I by Julia Quinn

Have I ever read the first Bridgerton novel before? I'm not sure that I have, so I picked it up for some light summer reading. Quinn is very good at moving her plot along at a brisk pace and I mostly had a good time, although some of the dialogue-heavy "banter" scenes between siblings dragged a little for me. This book did cause me to wonder whether the contemporary trend for more explicit historical romance makes it date faster. Sexual mores are so fluid! When this was first published in 2000, the central conflict between the romantic leads — which is concerned with their physical relationship — probably felt quite risqué or even groundbreaking, but now it's both unconvincing and a little icky.


The Lighthouse by P.D. James

This is now the fourth P.D. James book I've read — I think — and I've yet to fall under her spell. Which is a shame, because I really want to! A lot of people I trust and admire speak very highly of her work, and she was such a major figure in late twentieth century crime fiction that I've always felt that I must be missing out. I picked up this 2005 mystery in a charity shop and was charmed by its setting on a fictional island off the coast of Cornwall. After being privately owned by the same family for centuries, the island is now operated by a trust as a completely private retreat for high profile politicians and other people for whom security issues mean they can never relax.

The discovery of a body amidst this secretive atmosphere requires Adam Dalgliesh and his team to be choppered in to solve the crime. It's all very dramatic, with crashing waves and high cliffs. A promising premise indeed. But the mystery didn't play fair to my mind, nor were the motives or characters well established. The way the story was told felt very "of its time" in a moderately unpleasant way, as did some of the major plot elements, which is not something I usually find frustrating in a book published only twenty years ago. Unless I find a very compelling reason to do otherwise, I probably won't pick up another P.D. James book.


The Boy with the Bronze Axe by Kathleen Fidler

As someone who spends part of each year in Orkney, I've been to Skara Brae a fair few times. Every time a friend or family member comes to visit, in fact. If you're not familiar, this is one of the best-preserved Neolithic settlements in the world, a village built on a sandy beach in the west of the Orkney mainland. The dwellings are 5,000 years old and were preserved under sand dunes for thousands of years before a storm uncovered them in 1850. Although it is undoubtedly an exciting archaeological site and a well-run visitor experience, I've never really connected with it emotionally in the way I do with some historic sites. It's interesting but not imaginatively engrossing to me.

Then I picked up this book in a secondhand shop. Published in 1968 and intended for younger readers (probably what we would now call middle grade?), it's a story woven through what we know of the history of Skara Brae, focusing on a single family in the run up to the great storm that drove the people there to abandon their settlement. Suddenly, I found the history much more absorbing, especially since I recognised lots of the archaeological details — such as a broken string of beads — that had been given a fictional explanation in the story. Perhaps I need to find more patience for Neolithic things in glass cases (Orkney has a lot of these), but once I'd read this children's book about Skara Brae, I suddenly found the life people once lived there much more comprehensible.


Tragedy at Law by Cyril Hare

This was the Shedunnit Book Club's chosen title for September, so as usual I was reading it a month ahead to be able to prepare the bonus episodes about it for members. It's a 1942 murder mystery based on the author's own experiences of being a judge's marshal (essentially a ceremonial bodyguard) for a circuit judge in the early days of WW2. The judge in question keeps receiving death threats and making questionable decisions in his personal life, and the marshal looks on, a bewildered amateur sleuth. The crime doesn't actually come until very late in the book, but Hare does such a good job of building up the tension that you don't mind. A very well-constructed whodunnit, rightly considered a classic and beloved by the legal profession.


Skipshock by Caroline O'Donaghue

I borrowed this from the library ebook service because I enjoyed the author's young adult fantasy series All Our Hidden Gifts. (She's better known these days for her literary/romantic fiction, though I've yet to explore that aspect of her output.) This book is also in the fantasy zone, but I think intended for adult or slightly older readers. It follows a wonderfully classic template, which I really enjoyed: main character Margo is on a train to Dublin when something strange happens and she slips into another dimension. A stranger called Moon helps her and explains that she is now in a world where time is everything — rich cities in this world have long days and in the poorer ones night comes in as little as six hours, radically reducing life expectancy and economic potential. A shadowy authority is tightly controlling movement between timezones, so that the time-poor cannot move to where the hours are more plentiful. In contrast to The Midnight Bargain, above, I did feel like the world was fully realised and described here, yet this addition didn't slow down the momentum of the plot. I'm realising that this balance is very important to me in fantasy books. Anyway, as the adventure continues, Margo and Moon get pulled into a resistance movement and become spies... Only for this book to end on a shocking cliffhanger because it's the first part of a duology. I will certainly be borrowing the other part when it is published.


Venetia by Georgette Heyer

By this point in my year of reading all of Heyer's detective fiction, I had become curious about her other (much more popular) work. This book in particular, a Regency romance set in 1818, had come up in a few secondary sources as being one of her best. So I grabbed it from the charity shop and devoured it in two sittings. It was great fun! I think today it would be called a "grumpy-sunshine" romance, because the personalities of the two lead characters fall on either side of that dichotomy. The title character is feisty but not irritatingly so, and her solution to the romantic problem that the plot sets up for her is clever and funny. I like how Heyer peppers her dialogue with Regency slang, too. On this evidence, I think I might like Heyer's non-crime fiction more than her crime fiction!


That was, belatedly, my reading for August: 9 books, bringing me up to 86 for the year to date. I'm a bit ahead of the pace needed to hit my target of 120 books read in 2025.

I know I said in January that one of my goals this year was to read more non-fiction and fiction in other genres but... that doesn't seem to who I am this year. I didn't read a single non-fiction book this month, and pretty much everything else was crime, romance or fantasy (or some combination thereof). I wasn't very well this month, so I think I gravitated towards the familiar.

If you would like to follow along in real time, you can see what I'm reading at any given moment on the Storygraph. I just use that as a tracker, though, I don't publish any reviews there. I am trying to catch up with these reviews before the end of the year...

Some book links are affiliate links, meaning that the podcast receives a small commission when you purchase a book there (the price remains the same for you).

Filed under: Blog, Reading Updates
2 min read Permalink

Optimising Yourself Should Not Be A Leisure Activity!

Thirteen things this Thursday that I have read, watched, listened to or otherwise found noteworthy.

The most popular link last time was this anti cosmetic surgery essay, with this piece about how to include kids at gatherin gs without centering them second.


  1. Rachel Cooke, a wonderful journalist who I got to edit occasionally when I worked at the New Statesman, died last week at the wildly young age of 56. This tribute from one of her colleagues at the Observer does a good job of capturing the breadth and depth of her talents.
  2. This — Alive Internet Theory — is the closest thing to a browser-based art installation that I've yet experienced. It describes itself as a "séance with the living internet" and uses the Internet Archive to create a dynamic collage of everything that has happened online since the beginning. It's quite a sensory experience to let it just play in front of you. And if anything catches your eye, you can click on it and be taken to the original webpage.
  3. I must confess, I have not actually listened to the album that this interview is intended to promote. But I liked hearing these two solo musicians (Finneas and Ashe) discuss why they decided to form a band and make a mostly-analogue record even though it wasn't the commercially savvy thing to do.
  1. There needs to be a Pixar short about this newly-discovered type of deep sea snailfish immediately.
  2. Naomi Alderman has a few words of sanity about AI-proofing your working life. Focus on honing the skills of discernment, research and perseverance, and absolutely "do not let the AI do the work for you before you have learned how to do it yourself".
  3. Productivity Videos Are The Bane Of Productivity, because while we're watching people on YouTube showing us how to be more efficient, we're not being efficient at all. Optimising yourself should not be a leisure activity!
  4. This piece made me weirdly jealous of Dua Lipa, but not in the way you might think.
  1. Molly Young is keeping a running treasury of really good book dedications. The one above is from Epitaph of a Small Winner by Machado de Assis, sent in by Tim Berge.
  2. The man who made that incredible marble musical instrument a decade or so ago seems to be having a slow-motion nervous breakdown while trying to top it? (Thanks to Uri for this link.)
  3. The writer Susan Orlean is a style icon of mine. Here she is explaining how she packed for a 25-city book tour.
  4. If you watch Toy Story today, it looks different to how it did when first released in 1995. This is — broadly — because it was made during a time of transition in animation. Computers were smart enough to make this kind of film but not smart or widespread enough to screen it in cinemas. So it was printed down on to standard 35mm film for theatre and home release. Then, later, they did a digital transfer and that's the version you can stream today. Fascinating to think that our instinctive "films looked better when I was a child" reaction might actually be rooted in fact rather than nostalgia.
  5. We once loved pigeons.
  6. Reportage from Thessaloniki, supposedly a "city that forgot itself".

Filed under: Blog, Links
2 min read Permalink

I'm Having A Really Nice Time Reading All The Footnotes

Thirteen things this Thursday that I have read, watched, listened to or otherwise found noteworthy.

The most popular link last time was this side-by-side comparison of US vs UK book covers, with this podcast episode about the witch economy second.


  1. A magnificent 7,000-word essay about what on earth is going on with women and cosmetic surgery.
"I firmly believe we will look back on the 'the filler and facelift era' with all the ignominy of the dust bowl farmers who, hypnotized by the prospect of UNLIMITED WHEAT, over-plowed hundreds of miles of protective native grasslands until their children’s lungs became so blackened with dirt that they could do nothing but impotently weep while their offspring suffocated in their sleep."

2. Browse an archive of historical playing cards and tarot decks, including this 1910 suffragette deck and this 1870 "chinois" take on tarot. Fun bonus fact: this non-profit archive was set up by a fairly senior Google AI guy.

  1. One for the dog owners: why does a Kong look the way it does? Because of a rubber axel stop and a German shepherd named Fritz.
  1. Hayley Williams is everything to me.
  2. How a New Yorker cover inspired a years-long obsession with front doors.
  3. What even is "literary" fiction"? When examined critically, many of the default responses to this question break down.
"It’s true that a lot of genre fiction relies on common tropes and patterns. But then, how many literary fiction submissions have I received in the last month about a young woman getting too involved in the fraught marriage of an older couple?"
  1. I suspect some parents might find this piece exasperating, but I thought it was an interesting take on the fraught "how to mingle kids and adults socially" question: how to include kids without centering them.
  2. Rebecca Makkai's Zillow critiques are always great fun. This one contains the sentence "we really need to talk about sarcophagus placement".
  3. On choosing friction in the age of AI. Possibly related: I have started reading War and Peace, a thing I swore I would never do, and I'm having a really nice time reading all the footnotes about the Napoleonic wars.
  4. A collection of data analyses on romance books, including "best of the best" lists for various subgenres.
  5. On finishing a big project — in this case, a very very long hike — and not really feeling anything.
  6. Interesting: "obsessive investigation" as its own non-fiction classification.
  7. It is once again the time of year when I become deeply invested in ballet vloggers.

Filed under: Blog, Links
1 min read Permalink

Lady C: The Long Sensational Life of Lady Chatterley’s Lover

My husband Guy Cuthbertson has a new book coming out next year, in May 2026:

It tells the story of Lady Chatterley's Lover by D.H. Lawrence over the last century, which I have very much enjoyed learning about over the past few years as he has been working on it. Here's the full blurb from Yale University Press:

D. H. Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover is one of the best-known and most resonant works of the twentieth century. Originally considered obscene and unpublishable in numerous countries, its scandalous story of class divide and the English countryside is infamous. But, since the 1920s, we have repeatedly re-created Lady Chatterley, from film and TV to music and tourism.
Guy Cuthbertson tells the colourful story of the novel’s journey through the last hundred years. He examines how the book has been read, adapted, and reimagined across the globe, from the United States to Japan, and explores the 1960 “Chatterley trial”—a key moment in the struggle for freedom of expression. It might have been burnt and derided, laughed at and defaced, but Lawrence’s novel has crept into all walks of life. Whether the book, or its influence, be good or bad, we live in a world that Lady Chatterley’s Lover helped to create.

Here are some places where you can pre-order the book:

Links with a * are affiliate links, meaning that I receive a small commission when you purchase a book there (the price remains the same for you).

Filed under: Blog